A Tea Addict's Journal

The curse of the golden flowers

May 29, 2007 · 8 Comments

I had plans to drink another sample sent to me by iwii today. Among the stuff he sent me were a few pieces of a heavily traditionally stored tea. As most of you who regularly read my blog know, I’m a good Hong Kong boy and do not mind traditional storage so long as it fulfills two conditions

1) It is not so wet stored as to have health concerns for me
2) It is not presented as a dry stored tea of significantly older age and thus selling for a price it doesn’t deserve

As I was flipping the few pieces of tea around for picture taking, however, I noticed something

Not clear enough? Try looking at the picture here.

See those yellow dots in the middle? There are conflicting information regarding these things. Some call it “golden flowers”, and claim that they are good for you. Others say that there are two types of golden flowers — one is the good kind, the other is a harmful kind that is really a mould that will produce a carcinogenic toxin. Needless to say, I was a little alarmed to find this. I then searched around the pieces some more… there were more of these on other pieces, scattered around, and also some white mould

As well as that white dusting that covers pretty much everything, inside and out.

Properly traditional stored tea should have some of these white dusting, but white mouldy spots or yellow ones are generally considered bad. I put off the tea and brewed some of my Mengku 2002, which I haven’t tried in at least half a year. I used the shavings that have accumulated inside the wrapper, plus a little off the cake. The tea brews a nice amber colour

It’s bitter, and strong, but smooth. There’s a strong taste to it…. something akin to dark chocolate. Obvious qi, with a bit of huigan, not quite hitting down the throat, but definitely towards the back end of the mouth. It’s not a great tea, but not a bad one either, and it now costs at least double what I got it for about 9 months ago.

While drinking it, however, I was sorely tempted to try the sample that iwii gave me. I was planning on throwing it out, but decided that I can at least brew it and see what happens.

I washed it a few times, and then brewed one infusion for trying. The obvious aroma coming from the tea is a medicinal smell, but not in a very aromatic way, rather in a slightly pungent and unpleasant way. I tried a few small sips of the tea, which brewed an almost pitch black drink. It’s surprisingly bitter, given that it’s been so wet stored. Normally teas like this should be fairly sweet and pleasant, but this one isn’t.

The leaves for this tea are rather rigid and inflexible

It’s lost much of its vitality, and I couldn’t really find many examples of leaves that were both whole and open-able. This was the best one after some exhaustive searching

Even then, it didn’t really open up, and it’s already gone through 5 very long infusions. Properly traditionally stored tea should only be lightly wet stored, and then dry stored for a few years to let the wet storage dissipate and develop before going on the market. This tea has been mismanaged — too wet, and not enough time/treatment afterwards to make it palatable. Perhaps given some years in a dry, airy environment it can be saved a bit, but I don’t think so. It’s quite far down the road to being a cooked puerh, if you examine the leaves. There isn’t a whole lot that can happen to it, and the existence of the yellow mould pretty much seals the deal. Whoever sold this cake is doing a disservice to tea drinkers it serves.

So, iwii, where did you get this cake? You should ask for your money back, especially if they told you it’s dry storage or it’s 30 years old (which it can’t be).

Categories: Old Xanga posts · Teas
Tagged: ,

8 responses so far ↓

  • iwii // May 29, 2007 at 10:58 am | Reply

    Yes this tea is badly wet stored. This sample is coming from a Store in Paris called “Maison du trois thes”.
    You definitely used too much tea, as it should be very bitter indeed with such a large quantity. With a smaller amount, I think it tastes actually rather good, but this is not the point here.
    The thing is that they claim it is from 98, but It can’t be. They have numerous cakes like this, from absurd years like the 80’s and so forth…
    Because this one is claimed to be 10 years old, the cake is sold 150 Euros, so about 200 USD or so. No need to say more I guess…

  • iwii // May 29, 2007 at 11:02 am | Reply

    Oh I forgot to put a disclaimer here! As I do not want to be accused of trying to poison MarshalN, I have to make clear I told him this sample was for reference only, and that he could feel free to trash it. Thanks for your attention, and thank you MarshalN for your spirit of sacrifice!

  • MarshalN // May 29, 2007 at 11:05 am | Reply

    Ouch… expensive…

    What kind of wrapper does it come in?  Do you know?

  • iwii // May 29, 2007 at 11:34 am | Reply

    I have not a whole cake, and no wrapper, but I have seen it. It is really looking similar to the Jinzhu mountain round tea cake one. There are many copies of that one.

  • kibi_kibi // May 30, 2007 at 12:49 am | Reply

    mmm tasty… I think the leaves of the cheapest of shou look more tempting than that 😉 How could someone sell this?


  • iwii // May 30, 2007 at 2:44 am | Reply

    Well Vlad, I have no other samples from there left unfortunately, but I can ensure you it is not the worst looking cake I have seen from that shop. They have tons of clients apparently, they have a very famous reputation and the owner is supposed to be one of the most famous tea master in the world and blah blah blah… you got the point…
    They also sell teapots at prices ranging from 1000 to 2000 dollars if I remember well, given the fact that they are able to sell obvious fake tea cakes at these prices, I would not really see why both these pots and this reputation would be genuine, since it is far more difficult to detect fakes in this case. I haven’t seen their pots though, so I can’t tell.

  • MarshalN // May 30, 2007 at 5:11 am | Reply

    kibi_kibi, you’re right in that even shou (I don’t know about the cheapest) leaves should be more flexible/lively than these.  These are…. rather dead looking.  They look worse in person when you realize that none of them will open up, even after a few minutes of brewing in very hot water.

    Like I said… failed wet storage.  I guess if you want to sell it in a retail store to people who don’t really know that much of the various things that happen to puerh, it’s not an impossible sell.  If you use low amounts of leaves with long infusions, anything will taste pretty good. 

    Which Jinzhu cake?  The Changtai one?  But Changtai factory isn’t even 10 years old.

  • iwii // May 30, 2007 at 5:39 am | Reply

    I would use a low amount of leaves, but not long infusions with this tea apart from the rinse to get rid of the toxins you mentioned (irkkk, thinking I drunk it myself…), no wonder it’s bitter otherwise!
    For Changtai that’s a good remark, but who would believe it is 10 years old anyway?
    Actually, I did not say it was that very cake, but that it looked similar. This is probably one of the numerous copies I mentioned above.

Leave a Comment